Woohoo!! Thanks to everyone for your very encouraging comments!! I was hoping to find out which designs were favorites, but it looks like they are all equally loved :)
Comments #14 and #15 were from the same person, so I only counted them as one.
I used Random.org to pick a winner, but I can't figure out how to show the actual screen shot of the result, so I guess you'll have to trust me :) And I had a witness ...
The winner is #17!!
Congratulations Robin!! I'll email you today for your address!!